DSM: mv07b_junk

From: Scott David Gray (sgray@aramis.sudval.org)
Date: Sun Feb 17 2002 - 09:32:10 EST


   [1x1.gif] Home-[home.gif]

   Search the Globe's archives-[archivessign.gif]

   Boston Globe Online: Page One-[npageone.gif]
   Nation | World-[nnation.gif]
   Metro | Region-[nmetro.gif]
   Living | Arts-[nliving.gif]

   Automotive-[nautomotive.gif] Classifieds-[nclassifieds.gif]
   Focus-[nfocus.gif] Learning-[nlearning.gif] Real
   estate-[nrealestate.gif] Travel-[ntravel.gif]

   Local news
   - City Weekly
   - Globe South
   - Globe West
   - North Weekly
   - NorthWest Weekly
   - New Hampshire


   Search the Globe:
   ___________ [Today.....] [search.gif]-Submit


                       [mv07b_junk_01.gif]-Submit [mv07b_junk_02.gif]-Submit
   [--- Your State ---] [mv07b_junk_04.gif]-Submit
   The Boston Globe Online-[logoglobe249.gif] Boston.com-[logowave.gif]
   Boston Globe Online / Sunday | Learning-[learningban500.gif]

   [ Send this story to a friend | Easy-print version | Search archives ]



   Seek and they shall learn

   By Laura Pappano, Globe Staff, 2/17/2002

   I t sounded so outrageous, that I had to see for myself: A school with
   no grades, no tests, no homework, no curriculum, and no teachers.
   There also is no schedule. As long as students spend five hours a day
   at school, they can show up when they want. And while they're there,
   they can do what they choose.

   As I walked toward the mansard-roofed mansion that houses the main
   building of the Sudbury Valley School in Framingham one recent
   morning, one boy greeted another: ''Hey, I didn't think you were
   coming today.'' Nearby, two students rode unicycles while a basketball
   game broke out on a blacktop.

   Inside the school, which serves 210 children ages 4 to 19, barefoot
   little ones scurried by like fairies. Teens sunk into sofas in the
   main lounge debated something about music. In a small room, five girls
   arranged tiny clay figurines on a tabletop. Elsewhere, students bent
   over Magic cards, a role-playing game, while other students who enjoy
   writing were reading reading aloud.

   So what are these children learning? ''Nobody knows what kids are
   doing in this school on any day,'' said Mimsy Sadofsky, a member of
   the staff since the school was founded in 1968. ''It's based on a
   model of trust and the reason you have the trust is that you think
   people are going to be doing things that have interest to them and
   significance for their own personal growth.''

   It may appear unusual for parents to pay $4,750 a year to send their
   children to a private school where those in charge apparently have no
   idea what's going on. But that is precisely the point: It is the
   child's job - not the adult's - to initiate learning.

   And even what constitutes worthwhile learning is up to the child,
   based on the belief that children will seek out information they need.
   Many children, Sadofsky observed, have learned to read by playing
   Magic cards. One boy said he usually plays video games. Sadofsky said
   she learned long ago not to judge how students spent their days. ''I
   can't tell when other people are using their time well,'' she said.

   Students must be self-directed, so the school does not accept those
   with special needs. Sudbury Valley, Sadofsky said, may not be for
   everyone, which is why prospective students must spend a week at the
   school before enrolling.

   Sudbury Valley feels like an anomaly at a time when education fashion
   has schools carefully accounting for time, curriculum, and test
   results. Education reform has brought much-needed order to a chaotic
   educational landscape, particularly in urban areas where schools were
   more holding tanks than sources of inspiration.

   MCAS may make students pay attention, but can it make them learn?
   ''Ultimately, kids decide what they want to learn,'' said Ted Sizer,
   founder of the Coalition of Essential Schools and a visiting professor
   at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. ''Even as we adults think
   we're controlling them, we're not, particularly when they're

   Sizer, trustee of the Francis W. Parker Charter School in Devens,
   supports the state standards, but sees the worth of schools such as
   Sudbury Valley.

   ''One thing we really value in this country are people who can think
   for themselves, who are entrepreneurial thinkers, who see things
   people haven't seen before, who are imaginative,'' he said.

   Suzanne Gaffney's 16-year-old son, Jason, came to Sudbury Valley in
   the fall after spending his freshman year at Wayland High School.
   Students and parents at the suburban high school were too focused
   ''not just getting into college, but getting into a name-brand
   college,'' Gaffney said.

   Her goals for Jason were more grounded. ''We just want him to be
   happy,'' said Gaffney, who also was concerned about ''the whole
   teenage mentality of conforming, of being exactly alike'' when her son
   had always been a real individual.

   An affable youth who is involved in theater, Jason recently sat in
   Sudbury Valley's art room and painted glaze onto a fired clay ball, a
   small globe with land masses of unfamiliar shape. It was, he said, his
   redesigned world.

   And that is what students here do: They shape their own studies. Talk
   to students and you hear a passion for learning. Hannah Katch, 14, of
   East Woodstock, Conn., loves botany and Plato's dialogues. ''I just
   couldn't stop reading them,'' she said.

   Travis Weiner, 16, of Upton, who sat in the kitchen with a checked
   cloth napkin tucked into his shirt as he ate a vegetarian burrito,
   named his academic interests: writing, biology, math, history,
   philosophy, theology, and psychology. Right now he's reading a
   psychology text with a group of teens. ''It's analogous to a book
   group,'' he explained.

   Like many teens here, Weiner complains that many traditional schools
   favor memorizing facts, not fostering intelligence. Peter Berard 16,
   of Foxborough has spent much of his public school career ''stuck in
   classes I either had no aptitude in or no interest in. It's not the
   proper way to educate someone.''

   Myla Green, 18, of Ashland, has been at Sudbury Valley since she was 4
   and hopes to graduate this year. That requires her to defend a thesis
   and win approval in a schoolwide vote. Green earned a combined score
   of 1,220 on the SATs and plans to attend college. ''The most important
   thing you have here is time and freedom to do what you want,'' said

   Those are scarce commodities these days in education.

   Education reform has brought positive change. But in the quest to
   align schools to standards, are we pressing the belief that there is
   one path, one type of essay that earns a top score on the
   Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System, one ''right answer''?
   That learning is not an exploration, but a search for the appropriate

   In fifth grade, my teacher passed out paper with a large circle on it
   and several lines beneath. The assignment was to draw a picture and
   write something. I stared at the circle in the familiar shade of
   mimeograph ink and made a daring decision: I drew nothing and wrote
   about it. This was the 1970s. My teacher, 26 with longish hair and a
   passion for the Beatles and ''The Hobbit,'' thought it was brilliant.

   Would a teacher now appreciate such a response? Perhaps. What is more
   troubling, though, is that I don't think a student today would try it.
   What's refreshing - even moving - about the Sudbury Valley School is
   the confidence with which they assert the belief that there is more
   than one way to get an education.

   Send feedback and story ideas to Laura Pappano by e-mail at

   This story ran on page G1 of the Boston Globe on 2/17/2002.
    Copyright 2002 Globe Newspaper Company.

   [ Send this story to a friend | Easy-print version | Search archives ]

   [1x1.gif] [1x1.gif]

   [1x1.gif] [1x1.gif]

   [teasehousesmall1.gif]-[teasehousesmall1.gif] Save 50% on home
   delivery of The Boston Globe

    Copyright 2002 Boston Globe Electronic Publishing Inc.
   | Advertise | Contact us | Privacy policy |


If you wish to be removed from this mailing list, please send an email TO
majordomo@sudval.org (do NOT reply to the mailing list) with the following
phrase in the BODY (not the subject) of the message, replacing
"email@host.dom" with the email address that you subscribed under:

unsubscribe discuss-sudbury-model email@host.dom

If you are interested in the subject, but the volume of mail sent is too much,
you may wish to consider unsubscribing from this list and subscribing to

This mailing list is archived at http://www.sudval.org/~sdg/archives

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0.0 : Wed Mar 27 2002 - 19:39:49 EST