DSM: Unsolicited help

From: Ardeshir Mehta, N.D. (ardeshir@sympatico.ca)
Date: Fri Jan 25 2002 - 20:46:51 EST

Hi Joe,

Re. this:

> > I don't get your point. Are you saying that all un-requested
> > offerings of help are bad? Why, in heaven's name?
> Hi Ardeshir. I don't want to put words into anybody's mouth, but in my
> estimation, knowing as a staff member what is beneficial or harmful to
> the school environment is much more of an art than a science.
> Certainly, if I was staffing (currently I am not regular staff, but
> substitute once in a blue moon) and a student was carrying something
> very heavy, or a student was hurt or crying, I would immediately offer
> help or comfort. On the other hand, I would likely not walk up to a
> student having trouble with a problem or another student and attempt to
> offer help.

Right. The second kind of "help" is a bit like offering a lift in a car
to a jogger!

> I think the trick here is for staff members to be sensitive to how
> quickly and easily the helpful intentions of adults can take the
> initiative away from the students. My sense is that you, Ardeshir, would
> likely have an excellent intuitive feel of this dynamic were you to see
> it in action! (As you know, some things have to be felt and not
> explained)


> One of the things that happens, though, is that so many newcomers cannot
> distinguish between unsolicited adult help lifting something heavy and
> unsolicited adult help learning to read. Staff members and founders get
> in the habit of pushing the button of "now you *do* realize in these
> schools that students have to initiate everything and we are *not* going
> to pull them along" in presenting the school and in admissions in order
> to really make sure parents understand this.

But this is not common sense. I have not personally seen any Sud-
bury school in action, but I HAVE visited Summerhill in England,
and read virtually everything its founder, A.S. Neill, has ever
written: and he was always in favour of using common sense. If the
Sudbury philosophy is so greatly opposed to common sense, then
I am afraid I do take exception to it!

It's also not the way adults treat one another. I have lived for years
on end in four different countries, and visited at least a dozen for
shorter periods, and even vacationed in Cape Cod a couple of
summers; and I donít remember in any place that I have lived in or
visited wherein adults did NOT offer unsolicited help AT ALL to
one another. Even on the Israeli kibbutzim, where the people are
the rudest I have ever met -- and even take pride in being rude! --
when help is offered, though it may be unsolicited, it is accepted
gladly, though sometimes gruffly.

> Founders and staff become very sensitive to the general difficulty
> people have in understanding our schools, so when they hear people say
> "yes, yes but when genuine help is obviously needed we should give it",
> it raises alarms. At face value, of course this remark seems to miss
> the point or disregard the prime directive of Sudbury schooling, which
> imo is to have an environment wherein kids learn to start and follow
> through with their learning processes on their own initiative. The idea
> is that this instills a high degree of *internal* discipline, as opposed
> to the *external* discipline that traditional schools apply.

Of course. On the Israeli kibbutzim too the aim is to have everyone
exercise as much initiative as possible. They HAVE to do it: after
all Israel is a pretty hard environment to live in, and without initia-
tive where would they end up? But as I said, even there one often
finds unsolicited help both offered and accepted. even with thanks.

I just donít see the justification for over-reaction, frankly, by
making it a "prime directive" never to offer help. I think we should
all behave toward one another like adults, and use a modicum of
common sense when doing so! Then I'm pretty sure we will all get
along quite well. And as adults we all offer unsolicited help quite
often -- in EVERY kind of society.

> This might be why you have gotten a reaction which seems to paint the
> picture of a school wherein staff won't help a child with a broken arm
> if they don't ask for the help. However, I'm pretty sure that you would
> "get it" if you had the opportunity to step into one of these schools
> some day.:)

Yes, of course. But I donít mean just a broken arm. Most times I
myself have been offered unsolicited help, and was glad of it, was
when I did not know that such help was at all even AVAILABLE.
It happens to me even nowadays, and I am almost 60 years of age!
It happens with many sorts of things: for example, with help with
my computer, with cooking or doing the dishes, with the Theory of
Relativity, and in all kinds of different matters, important and un-
important. If I donít want the help I say so! But most often I find
the unsolicited help I am offered very -- ahem -- helpful.

All the best,

Ardeshir <http://homepage.mac.com/ardeshir/AllMyFiles.html>.


If you wish to be removed from this mailing list, please send an email TO
majordomo@sudval.org (do NOT reply to the mailing list) with the following
phrase in the BODY (not the subject) of the message, replacing
"email@host.dom" with the email address that you subscribed under:

unsubscribe discuss-sudbury-model email@host.dom

If you are interested in the subject, but the volume of mail sent is too much,
you may wish to consider unsubscribing from this list and subscribing to

This mailing list is archived at http://www.sudval.org/~sdg/archives

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0.0 : Wed Mar 27 2002 - 19:39:49 EST