Re: DSM: Re: Subtle Coercion?


The Booroobin Sudbury School (booroobin@squirrel.com.au)
Mon, 8 Jan 2001 10:53:51 +1000


Hi, Derek here from The Booroobin Sudbury School,
There is a difference between a statement and a request for assistance.
There is also a difference between leading and giving direction on the one
hand, and responding to a request for assistance. The adult stated: >>she
has little interest in reading. The response in a SVM environment would be
to acknowledge the statement. The person making the statement / declaration
wasn't expressing a need for help. On the other hand the other adult
thought it was "sad". Doing things for someone else doesn't give the person
the means to work it out for themselves, and generate self-reliance. The
other person will come to the conclusion when they see a need to read.
The Booroobin Sudbury School
http://booroobinschool.squirrel.com.au
Ph/fax +61 07 5499 9944
----- Original Message -----
From: "Alan Klein" <Alan@klein.net>
To: <discuss-sudbury-model@aramis.sudval.org>
Sent: Monday, January 08, 2001 8:56 AM
Subject: Re: DSM: Re: Subtle Coercion?

> Someone (I forget who) gave this example of an adult-adult interaction:
>
> > > Here's an example: I have an adult friend who recently told me she
has
> > > little interest in reading. I balked at this as I find it quite sad
and
> > > offered that she try some children's books which are easier and which
I
> > > frequently read myself. She did not ask me if I knew any good
> > > ones or if I
> > > knew where she could get one, but I took the initiative and offered
"The
> > > Giver" as I'd read it recently and really enjoyed it. She took
> > > it and read
> > > it and liked it of her own volition. Hers was the freedom to
> > > choose to read
> > > it or not to read it. It had nothing to do with my not making the
> > > suggestion for fear of forcing her into it. That would have been
> absurd.
> >
> Joe responded:
> > Well, if by using this as a test case of something that would be
> > inappropriate for a staff to say to a student, then you are correct.
>
> Joe (and others who may agree with him),
>
> I would like to hear more about your view of this as an inappropriate
> staff - student interaction. It sounds perfectly reasonable to me. There
is
> no coercion and the other person brought up the subject. The "staff"
person
> simply responded with their own take on the situation and with a
suggestion.
>
> ~Alan Klein
>
>



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Thu Mar 29 2001 - 11:16:01 EST